Hello Fellow Yuneec Pilot!
Join our free Yuneec community and remove this annoying banner!
Sign up

This may seem silly, but is there chance drones could be fueled by diesel or gas, instead of batteries, like old 'Cox engines'?

Joined
Aug 27, 2017
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Age
53
This may seem silly to some, but dead serious to engineers and designers, but is there chance that drones could revert to diesel or gas fueled engines, like older 'Cox' remote controlled aircraft were?

I mean if reverted back to gas or diesel mini engines, battery issues totally eliminated.

Am I way off base on this or 'right on'?
 

Attachments

  • cox engine.PNG
    cox engine.PNG
    201.6 KB · Views: 15
That's not so silly - I have already seen petrol-powered multirotors on commercially available agricultural systems and in prototypes for manned craft, but really it's swapping one set of problems for another. Not only are the petrol equivalents heavier and less economic, they are also many times louder, cost more both initially and to continually fuel, so it mainly makes sense when you need extended flight times.

Edited: Removed some stuff in light of corrections from below !
 
Last edited:
Just the opposite where fire safety is concerned, unless dealing with a hot turbine engine. Lipo batteries have caused far more fires than liquid fueled model aircraft engines have. Even the more flammable fuel gasoline engines have a better safety record.

Modelers switched to battery power not because it was safer, they did it to obtain more power for the amount of mass and weight involved. As model flights are typically of short duration a high output battery-motor combination could be used that was smaller dimensionally and more efficient. Combustion engines are at best 30% efficient where an electric motor can exceed 80% efficiency. Torque response is nearly instant with an electric motor where a liquid fueled engine builds torque more slowly. There is also a smoother power curve with an electric motor because it does not possess the shock impulses of a combustion motor. Remove the shock impulses and a lighter engine mount can be used. Combine torque with propeller efficiencies and faster torque response and you have things of serious consideration in some types of RC flying.

The problem with electric power is carrying the battery weight necessary for long duration flight. An aircraft capable of carrying enough batteries to fly for a couple hours would have to be quite large in size, wingspan, and weight, which is counter productive. That same plane could carry enough liquid fuel to fly many hours at a lower weight using a well tuned combustion engine.

The issue is in finding a balance that can maximize use of available energy densities, at a cost that doesn’t break the bank. This is extremely critical with multirotors as the only devices generating lift is the motors and propellers. When they stop a multirotor has the glide ratio of a grand piano where a well designed winged drone can achieve a glide ratio in excess of 20-1. Those wings generate lift and lift helps carry weight.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DCH

New Posts

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
20,977
Messages
241,831
Members
27,384
Latest member
TroyBoy